Combing initial LIGO data for the potentially strong continuous wave emitter Scorpius X-1

We present results of a search for continuously emitted gravitational waves from the neutron star in the brightest low-mass X-ray binary (LMXB), Scorpius X-1. The analysis covers 10 days of data from LIGO's 5th science run (S5) in the frequency band ranging from 50 to 550 Hz. Since no signal was detected, we set 95% confidence upper limits on the signal strength of the gravitational-wave emission, constraining the ellipticity of the neutron star in Scorpius X-1.

Neutron stars with small deviations from rotational symmetry are the most likely sources of continuous gravitational waves detectable by ground-based detectors such as LIGO. Although the resulting gravitational-wave signals are expected to be very weak, they are continuous and long-lived, permitting prolonged measurements, which improve sensitivity. These measurements work better when there are fewer unknown parameters required to describe the signal. For an isolated neutron star, its location on the sky and the gravitational-wave emission frequency are the main search parameters. However, many neutron stars have been found in orbital systems with other stars. A gravitational-wave source in an orbital system can require up to 5 additional parameters to describe the orbit of the system in order to fully model the gravitational-wave signal.

Low-mass X-ray binaries are binary systems consisting of a neutron star, black hole, or white dwarf in a binary orbit with a normal star of lower mass (usually a star quite like our own sun). The lower mass companion star is drawn into the gravitational field of the compact object, which starts shredding mass layers away from the normal star in a process called accretion. LMXBs are usually very well observed through their x-ray (and other) electromagnetic emissions, providing positional and orbital (and sometimes rotational) parameters, thereby reducing the uncertainty in the parameters we have to search over. Neutron stars in LMXB systems are interesting sources of gravitational waves because accretion provides a natural method of deforming the star away from rotational symmetry, powering the gravitational-wave emission.

Scorpius X-1 is the brightest LMXB in our galaxy and one of the closest to us, only 9000 light years away. It is well observed in several electromagnetic bands, giving us accurate information on several parameters including the sky position, orbital period and semi-major axis. However not all parameters of the system can be observed or accurately determined (for example, the neutron star spin frequency). A proposed balance between the accretion acting to make the neutron star spin faster and the gravitational-wave emission trying to slow it down would suggest that Scorpius X-1 is potentially one of the strongest continuous gravitational-wave emitters detectable by ground-based detectors.

We have developed a new program called Sideband to search efficiently for continuous gravitational waves from neutron stars in binary systems using only partial knowledge of the binary orbital parameters. As a first stage we analyse the data without accounting for the binary motion of the neutron star. This stage generates a well-defined pattern (a 'comb' of finely spaced sidebands, or teeth) in the spectral output that are due to the orbital motion. We can model the sideband pattern with information on the orbital period and semi-major axis, so we can re-analyse the output of the first stage to account for the binary motion without exact knowledge of all of the orbital parameters.

The search was tested on 10 days of S5 data covering the frequency band from 50-550 Hz. Unfortunately we were not able to claim any detection in the short stretch of initial LIGO data we analysed. However, we were able to place the most sensitive upper limits on the strength of a signal from Scorpius X-1 in the frequency band that was analysed. The search is computationally cheap and comparable in sensitivity to previous searches, despite using much shorter observation times. This makes it an appealing search to run as a first pass in the coming second-generation gravitational-wave detector era. Further work on extending the coherent time span beyond 10 days will allow even greater sensitivity in the exciting times to come.

Read more:


  • Neutron star: A neutron star is the relic of a massive star that has reached the end of its life. When a massive star has exhausted its nuclear fuel, it dies in a catastrophic way--a supernova--that often results in the formation of a neutron star: an object so massive and dense that atoms cannot sustain their structure as we normally perceive them on Earth.
  • LMXB: Low-mass X-ray binary systems consist of a neutron star, black hole, or white dwarf in a binary orbit with a normal star of lower mass (usually a star quite like our own sun). The lower mass companion star is drawn into the gravitational field of the compact object, which starts shredding mass layers away from the normal star in a process called accretion. The high energies involved in this process result in the emission of X-rays.
  • Accretion: Accretion is a process where the gravitational potential of a massive object pulls in matter from another object that is close enough in proximity. The infalling matter usually forms an accretion disk due to conservation of angular momentum. In this disk, gas spirals towards the centre, becoming hotter as gravitational potential is converted into thermal energy. The energy can be radiated away as infrared, visible, ultraviolet, and/or x-ray light. Accretion disks around white dwarfs, neutron stars, and black hole candidates that are in binary systems can radiate massive amounts of energy at the ultraviolet and x-ray frequencies; some of these binary systems are among the brightest x-ray sources in the sky.
  • Scorpius X-1: Scorpius X-1 is an X-ray source located roughly 9000 light years away in the constellation Scorpius. Scorpius X-1 was the first extrasolar X-ray source discovered, and outside of the Sun, is the brightest persistent X-ray (1-10 keV) source in the sky. It was the first of the LMXBs to be discovered.
  • Semi-major axis: The semi-major axis is the long axis of an elliptical orbit.
  • Upper limit: A statement on the maximum value some quantity can have while still being consistent with the data. Upper limits suggest a maximum strength that signals can have before they would have been detected, with a given confidence. For example, in this case we are interested in the maximum intrinsic gravitational-wave strain amplitude of a continuous wave signal arriving at Earth. We set a 95% degree-of-belief limit, meaning there is a 95% probability that the quantity is below this limit.
  • LIGO: The Laser Interferometer Gravitational-wave Observatory consists of two 4-km long interferometric gravitational wave detectors separated by around 3000 km (1900 mi) located in Livingston, LA and Hanford, WA in the United States.

An artist's impression of Scorpius X-1.

An artist's impression of the Scorpius X-1 LMXB system. (Courtesy of Ralf Schoofs)

Figures from the Publication

For more information on the meaning of these figures, see the preprint at

A plot of detection statistic against gravitational wave frequency

This figure shows results from the search across the full search band. The red dots show the maximum detection statistic from the 1-Hz sub-band indicated by the horizontal axis. The vertical axis indicates the statistical significance of the data point. The solid black curve represents the amplitude at which the data becomes significant above the noise. Points above this curve are highlighted by black stars to indicate artificial signal injections, green circles to indicate frequencies known to contain disturbances from noise and pink squares to indicate results that needed further investigation.

A plot of upper limits on strain amplitude

This plot shows the upper limits for the search as a function of frequency in the case where the orientation of the neutron star is assumed known from electromagnetic observations and used as prior information. The search frequency runs across the horizontal as in the previous figure. The vertical axis represents the gravitational wave strain amplitude, which is a measure of the strength of the signal. The solid grey curve presents the median upper limit for each frequency band, while the grey region extends from the minimum to the maximum upper limit in each 1-Hz sub-band. The solid black curve shows the expected upper limit for Gaussian noise at the S5 design sensitivity for comparison. These results indicate that the gravitational wave strain amplitude from the neutron star in Scorpius X-1 at the most sensitive region of the detector around 150 Hz is less than 8 x 10-25 at 95% confidence. The large spike around 350 Hz is due to large noise disturbances, hence the least sensitive results are returned around this frequency.

Find us on Facebook   Follow us on Twitter